DIY vs. Professional Roof Repairs: What You Need to Know

4 Jul 2024

Maintaining a roof is a critical aspect of homeownership. Whether you’re dealing with minor leaks, missing shingles, or more significant damage, the question often arises: should you tackle the repairs yourself or hire a professional? Both options have their pros and cons, and it’s essential to weigh them carefully before making a decision.

Let’s delve into the pros and cons of DIY roof repairs versus hiring a professional roofer.


DIY Pros


  • Perceived Cost Savings: The most obvious benefit of DIY roof repairs is the potential cost savings. By eliminating labour costs, homeowners could potentially reduce the overall expense.


  • Learning Experience: Tackling a roof repair can be a valuable learning experience, increasing your knowledge and skills for future home maintenance tasks.
  • Involvement: If you enjoy completing DIY projects, then participating in the roofing repairs yourself may help to give you a sense of accomplishment.
  • Scheduling Flexibility: DIY projects allow homeowners to work at their own pace and schedule and to avoid the need to coordinate with contractors.

DIY Cons

Safety Concerns

  • Accidents: Roofing is a hazardous job. Climbing ladders, working at heights, and handling tools can lead to serious accidents or injuries if proper precautions aren’t taken.
  • Weather Hazards: Unpredictable weather conditions can also pose significant risks, making roof repairs even more dangerous.

Unexpected Costs

  • Materials: When doing DIY roof repairs, you often need to buy materials in bulk – such as shingles, nails, or roofing cement – even if you only need a few. A professional roofer can use leftover supplies for other jobs, optimizing resources.
  • Tools: Tools required to complete roofing repairs can be expensive to buy or rent. Minimally, you will need a nail gun, an extension ladder, safety harness, and safety helmet.

Quality of Work

  • Lack of Expertise: Without professional training, DIYers may not achieve the same quality of work as experienced roofers, potentially leading to further issues down the line and voiding warranties on roofing materials.
  • Roofing Materials: Understanding the different types of roofing materials is crucial for choosing the best option for your home. Doing it yourself may lead to missing the important insights and expertise that a professional roofer can provide.
  • Missed Problems: Inexperienced homeowners might overlook underlying problems that professionals would identify and address, potentially causing more extensive damage over time.

Time and Effort

  • Time-Consuming: Roof repairs can be time-consuming, particularly for those without experience. The time spent on DIY repairs might outweigh the cost savings when considering potential lost income and personal time.
  • Physical Demands: Roofing is physically demanding work that is not be suitable for everyone, particularly those with physical limitations or health concerns.


Professional Roofer Pros

Expertise and Experience

  • High-Quality Work: Professional roofers bring the expertise and experience to ensure that repairs are done correctly and efficiently.
  • Problem Identification: Professionals can identify and address underlying issues that might not be apparent to the untrained eye, which prevents future problems.


  • Proper Equipment and Training: Roofers have the necessary safety equipment and training to handle the risks associated with roof repairs, minimizing the chance of accidents.
  • Insurance: Many professional roofing companies are insured, which offers protection in case of accidents or damage during the repair process.

Time Efficiency

  • Quick Completion: Professionals can complete repairs much faster than the average homeowner, which reduces the time your home is exposed to potential damage.
  • Convenience: Hiring a professional allows homeowners to avoid the physical and time demands of roof repairs, focusing on other priorities instead.


  • Labour Warranty: When you hire a professional roofer, the roofing contractor issues the labour warranty. It covers the workmanship from that contractor.
  • Manufacturer Warranty: For manufacturer warranty coverage, manufacturers require correct installation according to their instructions and building codes. Professional roofers are best equipped to meet these standards.

Professional Roofer Cons


  • Labour Costs: Hiring a professional roofing contractor can involve higher upfront costs compared to DIY repairs. However, the investment often pays off in terms of quality, safety, warranty coverage, and peace of mind.


  • Scheduling Conflicts: Depending on their workload and availability, scheduling repairs with a professional contractor may take longer than DIY repairs. Homeowners may need to wait for an appointment, especially during peak seasons or in emergencies.


  • Less Hands-On Experience: If you enjoy tackling DIY projects and gaining hands-on experience, hiring a professional may limit your involvement in the repair process.


When considering DIY roof repairs, certain circumstances might make it a feasible option:

Minor Repairs: For small issues like a missing shingle or minor leak, and if you have some roofing experience, DIY repairs could be appropriate.

Budget Constraints: If funds are limited and you’re confident in your abilities, tackling minor repairs on your own can be cost-effective.

Time Flexibility: DIY might be suitable if you have the time and flexibility to work at your own pace while adhering to safety measures.


In certain situations, hiring a professional roofing contractor is the smartest choice:

Complex Projects: For extensive repairs, complete replacements, or detailed tasks like flashing installation, professionals ensure the job is done correctly.

Safety Concerns: If you’re uncomfortable with heights or lack proper safety equipment and training, it’s best to leave roofing work to experts.

Warranty Considerations: Professional installation or repairs are often necessary to maintain warranties on roofing materials and ensure the roof’s longevity.

Time Constraints: For quick completion, especially with severe damage or leaks, professional contractors are the most efficient option.


Choosing Mountain West Roofing for your professional roofing repairs ensures expert, high-quality service tailored to your home’s needs. Our experienced team delivers precise craftsmanship using premium materials, guaranteeing durability and longevity. Customer satisfaction is our priority, providing personalized solutions and responsive communication. Trust Mountain West Roofing to protect and enhance the value of your home with our top-tier roofing services.

Ready to take your roofing system to the next level? Contact Mountain West Roofing today to learn more. 604-474-118